We've made it to Season 2! In this episode, we see the fallout from the car crash cliffhanger that ended Season 1. Dean's in a coma and almost dead, John's a...

Plushienatural hosts Amanda and Dean recap their experiences at Creation's Washington, DC Supernatural convention from November 1-3, 2019.

We made it! It's the end of Season 1 of Supernatural in episode 22, "Devil's Trap."

The Winchesters are in a tough spot this week in Season 1, Episode 21, "Salvation." Meg's killing John's friends in order to get him to hand over the Colt, w...

We're in the home stretch! This week we're kicking the Season 1 mytharc into high gear with Episode 20, "Dead Man's Blood."

This week's episode is a Goth's dream. Season 1, episode 19, "Provenance" features a creepy painting, a creepy doll, and an incredibly creepy little girl who...

It's a Weechester flashback fiesta this week in Season 1, episode 18, "Something Wicked."

This week, Amanda and the Winchestbears tackle one of her very favorite episodes, Season 1, episode 17, "Hell House."

It's one Hell of an episode this week as we discover the truth about Meg and her connection to the Monster of the Week.

It's a most dangerous game this week as Sam gets captured by some real freaks and Dean and his awesome partner Officer Kathleen have to save him from becomin...

It's the start of Amanda's least favorite plot arc (well, until season 7 rolled around) in Season 1, episode 14, "Nightmare," in which Sam's freaky visions l...

Oh, "Route 666." Such a promising title wasted on such a racist piece of crap episode. Join Dean for a quick recap before Amanda tears into this episode for ...

Join Dean, Sammy, and Amanda for a detailed discussion (seriously, the show is ~50 minutes long!) of Amanda's all-time favorite episode, "Faith." Find out how...

We're back! And we're experimenting with the format a little bit. This week's show is a Flash Review, like the ones we do over at our Patreon page for our su...

This week we're looking at Season 1, episode 10, "Asylum." Sam and Dean work a case in a haunted insane asylum, which gives Amanda the chance to rant about w...

This week, Amanda and the Winchestbears take a look at Season 1, episode 9, "Home." Amanda has real problems with the way Dean is treated by the episode's gu...

Show Notes So, we did something a little different this week. First, we covered both 1.07 “Hook Man” and 1.08 “Bugs,” because they’re terrible episodes that ...

It's the season 14 premiere, and we're giving you a taste of it for free! This Flash Review will be available to the public, both here and on the main Plushi...

This week, Amanda and the Winchestbears watched Season 1, episode 6, “Skin.” Amanda gushes about the opening scene and the crew who made it possible for 3 ti...