This week's episode is a Goth's dream. Season 1, episode 19, "Provenance" features a creepy painting, a creepy doll, and an incredibly creepy little girl whose favorite pastime is giving Colombian neckties. It also has the first potential love interest for Sam, a spunky girl named Sarah who insists on being part of the hunt.
Dean gives the Plot Recap and the Best Song of the Episode, Amanda gives the commentary (which includes a special listener giveaway!), and Sammy and Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better.
1.19 "Provenance" on SuperWiki
"Cartwright Curse" on TVTropes
Jodelle Ferland on IMDB
Direct download link: http://traffic.libsyn.com/plushienatural/1.19Provenance.mp3