The Winchesters are in a tough spot this week in Season 1, Episode 21, "Salvation." Meg's killing John's friends to get him to hand over the Colt, which Sam and Dean need to kill the Yellow-Eyed Demon, who's planning to attack a family in Salvation, Iowa. The episode ends with John getting captured by Meg and her demon brother and Sam trying to run into a burning building to get revenge on the YED.
Dean does the Plot Recap and the Best Song (of the Episode AND the Series). Amanda does the Commentary, in which she talks about why "Carry On Wayward Son" has been her favorite song since she was 12. Sammy helps Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better.
"Salvation" on Supernatural Wiki
Pastor Jim Murphy on Supernatural Wiki
Meg's tiny throat-slitting blade
Sebastian Spence on IMDB
Direct download link: http://traffic.libsyn.com/plushienatural/1.21Salvation.mp3